About these ads

The Cowboy Schools Me on Hunting

Brett Burke (left) and Clancy Phillips - two young rodeo competitors who read THE TEMPTATION and liked it. (Brett is going to star in a video trailer for the book shortly, once his latest black eye clears up.)

It’s no secret to readers of this blog that I was pretty clueless about rural life when I met the cowboy a little more than a year ago.

That doesn’t mean I wasn’t trying, though. I’d written a novel called THE TEMPTATION that I hoped was sort of like a ghost version of Twilight, featuring a dead teen cowboy and his living prep school girl soulmate. I thought I was doing something pretty awesome by featuring a rural cowboy kid in my book.

Anyway, along came the cowboy love of my life — after I’d written and sold (but not yet seen published) this book. We were like night and day, the cowboy and I. I was a liberal city woman, he was a rural conservative man. But we had lots in common in spite of these surface differences, chemistry I can only describe as fire-starting, and soon we found ourselves falling in love with one another.

I let my cowboy read the cowboy ghost manuscript, which was just heading off to my editor in New York City at the time. I did this to show him how enlightened I was — you know, for “reaching out” to rural teens.

It had sort of the opposite effect, however.

While the cowboy was pleased at how I was trying to break out of my city snobbery and ignorance, he found lots and lots of problems with what I’d written, because I didn’t know what the bleep I was talking about. Among those problems was the way I’d presented hunters and hunting — which is to say I’d shown hunting to be brutal, barbaric and stupid.

The cowboy patiently explained to me that I had it all wrong. The motives? I got wrong. The guns? I got wrong. The times of year? Wrong. The method and management? Wrong. Wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong.

My cowboy told me that hunting wasn’t usually done out of bloodlust, as I and my progressive faux-vegan buddies obnoxiously assumed. It was often done because families needed food, he told me. There was no better feeling in the world for many families than “bagging” a deer and knowing that there would be meat enough in the freezer for a while.

Brett and Clancy with fish.

Hunting (and fishing), he showed me, was also done as a tradition, a way to bond fathers to sons (and sometimes daughters and moms) and it was a tradition thousands and thousands of years old, tying human beings to the earth and its cycles.

I’d naturally known none of this, because I had been raised to mock and misunderstand hunters by my own urban academic semi-socialist culture, which was more than happy to eat meat — so long as they bought it sanitized and without eyes, at the local Whole Foods or hippie co-op.

In a detailed, beautifully written email the cowboy gently but firmly called me on my crap. He showed me a side of rural life I’d never been exposed to other than in crummy movies, and pulled back the curtain on a way of life I not only knew zero about but was also stereotyping in the most offensive ways.

I was embarrassed by my own assumptions and ignorance, but as so often happens when we feel shame for our wrongdoings, I learned and grew.

Because of the cowboy, I rewrote the book. I got to know hunters. I came to understand the tradition and sport in a way I never had before. It was humbling, and educational for me — and it saved the book.

Unless the cowboy had come into my life, the cowboy ghost novel would never have rung true for actual rural youth and their families.

The book in question was published this week, and already I am getting wonderful supportive feedback from rural teens who are finding a bit of themselves and their families reflected back at them in its pages.

I am grateful to my cowboy for opening my eyes, and my heart, to a new way of life, and for helping me to expand the limits of my own experiences as a writer so that I can more fully incorporate rural experiences into my work.

And I’m grateful to young people like Brett and Clancy, for reading the book and letting me know they liked it.

Now, for a bit of schooling for y’all. LOL

The city chick version of “cowboy kid”:

The real version:

Doh!

About these ads

Tagged: , , , , , , ,

7 thoughts on “The Cowboy Schools Me on Hunting

  1. Jess April 26, 2012 at 10:48 am Reply

    I can’t wait to read it!! And I really can’t wait to see the movie!

    • mizvaldes April 26, 2012 at 10:54 am Reply

      Thank you! Fingers crossed the movie gets made. I would LOVE to see a ghost cowboy love story set in the Southwest, just for the sunsets!

  2. Thirza Peevey April 26, 2012 at 10:52 am Reply

    Not to mention that you can get a Phd in animal behavior, and not know as much as one trapper or hunter. The trapper or hunter must be in the woods day in and day out, studying the ways of his prey, learning where they eat and where they sleep, when they rise and when they lie down, and searching for the faintest trace of them in the grass. They search for shed antlers to tell them where the big bucks live, they look for faint trails in the grass, they search for the impression of a body in the leaves, that might still be warm with the body heat of the deer that laid their overnight. They learn how fences and stones influence the paths the animal takes, where the buck rubs the velvet off his antlers, where the raccoon washes his meal and how he gets there across a downed limb, a fence rail, a stump and some stones, so that the only track he leaves is on the water’s edge. Fur, Fish and Game is one of my favorite magazines, even though I don’t hunt (yet) and I’m amazed at what an expert hunter knows.

    Kudos to the cowboy for speaking up, and to you for listening.

    • mizvaldes April 26, 2012 at 10:54 am Reply

      Thank you! So true, what you say. So much to learn in this life…

  3. Dee April 26, 2012 at 10:54 am Reply

    Great story! Just wait & see how much more Ur cowboy will show U! U’ll have a great ‘ride’!

    • mizvaldes April 26, 2012 at 1:44 pm Reply

      Thanks, Dee! He’s opened my eyes to so much already, and they just keep opening wider. xoxo

  4. littleaggeek April 26, 2012 at 4:07 pm Reply

    Oh we’re just weird.
    I’ve posted here before about how some of the things you post are so similar to my experiences in being a city gal dating a cowboy. Seems like you’re at it again! My cowboy used to guide hunts up in the Yukon for many years, as did many of his friends. So you can imagine how nervous I was after a few weeks of dating to bring up that I wasn’t sure if I really supported hunting or not.

    I had just gotten my gun license for work (putting down large stock is often fastest and most humane with a gun) and was debating over hunting, so figured why not bring it up with the hunter-cowboy? See what the guy who had done it had to say.

    Truth be told (more so the truth we revealed) was that I don’t support the bad hunters. They’re the reason he stopped guiding and the reason hunting gets a bad rep. We decided there’s a difference between hunting with respect for the animals, well placed and humane methods and the nature-intuition that Thirza Peevey described above vs. the brutish, nasty and evil “hunting”. Sad thing is, the latter perception is there for a reason. Some “hunting” is done poorly and doesn’t even deserve the name. But not all, and definitely not those that hunt well. They smear hunting with a bad brush that it doesn’t deserve.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 367 other followers

%d bloggers like this: